Second Circuit Court of Appeals Judge Denny Chin and Kathy Hirata Chin, a retired Big Law partner, were recently interviewed by Steve Cohen and Julia Levi for the New York Law Journal. The married couple, who are both members of the Asian American Bar Association of New York (AABANY), have spent the last two decades creating reenactments of monumental civil rights cases. Creating scripts is the result of collaborative work with attorneys and judges at AABANY.
In the article, published on July 28, Judge Chin and Kathy Chin discussed how reenactment scripts are created based on available trial transcripts, but difficulties often arise when they do not exist or are incomplete. Newspaper articles, depositions, letters, briefs, and court opinions are often combined with narration to create a comprehensive reenactment.
Additionally, reenactments have drawn interest more frequently in light of current events. For example, the Chins have performed their reenactment of the Vincent Chin trial more than 30 times over the past decade, but demand for the script increased during the rise in anti-Asian violence amid the COVID-19 pandemic. Similarly, intervening events and changes to precedent necessitated updates to the scripts. For example, in the Korematsu v. United States reenactment, the ending was changed after the Trump v. Hawaii decision announced the overturning of Korematsu.
While the reenactments are popular continuing legal education programs, they have also been performed in law schools, colleges, and even high schools. Students may be unable to understand the intricacies of particular laws but are able to grasp the compelling stories and impact of these historic cases. Judge Chin’s goal in performing these reenactments for younger audiences is “to make the reenactments accessible without watering them down.”
The interview ended with advice from both interviewees. “My biggest piece of advice I would impart to law clerks is to think big picture,” Judge Chin said. Kathy Hirata Chin’s advice was directed to attorneys just starting out. She emphasized the importance of building a network early on, with fellow attorneys and with clients. “Above all, try to learn to look around corners and figure out what next steps would be of most value to the client and the team,” she said.
Click here to read the full article (subscription required).